‘Before, it was a black box’: Platforms report how they delete illegal content in Germany

It’s been six months since Germany started enforcing a new law holding social networks accountable for the content they host, and last week, Facebook, YouTube and Twitter reported on the content they’ve deleted or blocked in that country so far. With similar regulation being considered in the U.K., politicians there are closely watching how German lawmakers are working with U.S. tech platforms.

The Network Enforcement Act, or NetzDG, requires platforms to take down suspected illegal content within 24 hours or seven days, depending on the charge, or risk eye-watering €50 million ($60 million) fines. Every six months the platforms are required to report their findings. Here are the headline numbers:

  • Twitter received 264,000 complaints and blocked or removed 11 percent of the reported content.
  • YouTube received 215,000 complaints and removed or blocked 27 percent of the reported content, most of which was hate speech or political extremism.
  • Facebook received 1,704 complaints and removed or blocked 21 percent.
  • YouTube removed nearly 93 percent of the content that needed to be blocked within 24 hours of receiving the complaint.
  • In 637 cases, Twitter took longer than 24 hours to remove content.
  • Most of Facebook’s content deletion took place within 24 hours and 24 took more than a week
  • YouTube asked for help from an outside law firm specializing in criminal law 40 times.

“The law shows the players are taking obligations seriously,” said Ruben Hofmann, a partner at law firm Heuking Kühn Lüer Wojtek. “Before the publication of the reports, it was a black box. The free word is well protected by Germany’s constitution and civil code. If we ask platforms to delete content, then the boundaries must be quite high, that it’s reached a criminal act.”

Critics of the law feared that platforms would go overboard in blocking content to avoid fines, threatening free speech. The law was imprecise in saying what content is illegal, which also gives platforms a lot of leeway.

With this being the first set of reports and each platform having different reporting tools, it’s hard to know if those fears are warranted.

For example, Facebook had a comparably low number of complaints, which critics suggested is because its NetzDG reporting feature is separate from its existing system to report violations of its community standards, while YouTube and Twitter baked those reporting features into their existing system for reporting violations.

The fact that the platforms blocked a small percentage of the content that was brought to their attention suggests they’re not overreacting, but it’s hard to tell without looking at each case on its own merits, said Hofmann.

The next set of reports due in six months will be looked at to see if there’s any change in how aggressively the platforms are taking down content. Germany’s Federal Office of Justice has said these reports will be used to reevaluate the law in 2020.

A neutral body set up and financed by the tech players but with governmental oversight would improve the current law, Hofmann said. “We don’t want private institutions to decide if content is criminal.”

The post ‘Before, it was a black box’: Platforms report how they delete illegal content in Germany appeared first on Digiday.

Powered by WPeMatico

How Wayfair is personalizing how you buy your furniture online

Subscribe to our weekly retail briefing for more exclusive coverage, interviews and analysis around the modernization of retail and e-commerce.

Online furniture retailer Wayfair wants its customers to have to do as little as possible when they’re picking items to buy.

Wayfair is creating digital experiences on its website and app that include personalized recommendations based on what the retailer knows about the customer, and visualization capabilities that are as close as possible to a physical in-store experience or having a designer visit a customer’s home.

“You don’t [always] exactly know what you’re looking for,” said John Kim, Wayfair’s global head of algorithms and analytics. “If customers log in and engage with our site, we’re able to be more effective at personalizing the site to them; we want to create idea boards.”

Wayfair, established in 2002, was an early entrant in e-commerce furniture market. As from upstarts like Amazon and traditional retailers like Lowe’s, Target and Walmart invest in virtual and augmented reality and other digital tools, Wayfair is focusing on creating as relevant an experience as possible for the customer by turning its web and app into a virtual concierge that guides the customer through the furniture buying process. Instead of focusing on specific pieces of furniture, it lets customers play with how different items might look in their home, recommending groups of items like a designer would do. They can search for a particular type of furniture by uploading a picture of something that resembles what they’re looking for; through a “Shop the Look” feature, customers can build a virtual room according to a particular style; and the app uses augmented reality to help customers see how a furniture item would look in their physical space.

“There are specific characteristics about the home that make it a unique problem to solve; the home is highly visual, we’re dealing with products that are very large and bulky and can’t be dropped by drone,” Kim said. Wayfair’s competitive advantage is its focus on furniture and ability to create curated digital experiences, he said.

Wayfair rolled out digital personalization tools early, with augmented reality features available two years ago, and image searches and “Shop the Look” features going live last year. Building the tech in-house gives it a leg up, Kim said, and despite its digital-only delivery model, it’s staking a competitive position by adding phone support and offering customers opportunities to consult professional designers who use its tech platform to offer added value. The more the site knows about the customer based on search behavior, the more relevant the recommendations and product listings.

“One of our biggest challenges is making sure our vast catalog most relevant, otherwise a big catalog can actually hurt you,” he said.

The company, however, faces competitive pressure from Amazon and other brick-and-mortar retailers that are investing in digital capabilities. Brendan Witcher, principal analyst at Forrester Research, said furniture is a difficult area in which to make inroads through an entirely digital business model. As furniture retailers focus on hybrid digital-physical delivery methods, large, established companies have an advantage, he added.

“Legacy companies have more tools in their kit to win the customer; with Walmart acquiring jet.com, they’re flexing their muscles and their objective now is how to create an excellent digital experience,” he said.

A digital-only brand and a marketing strategy based on search also means higher customer acquisition costs. According a report from Jaime Katz, senior equity analyst at Morningstar, over the last five years, Wayfair has spent an average of 12.5 percent of sales on advertising, while Williams-Sonoma has averaged seven percent, RH 6 percent and Bed Bath & Beyond 3 percent. Still, Katz wrote that Wayfair’s advantages in the market are its breadth of product offerings and its logistics network which allows for faster delivery of its products compared to most of its peers. Meanwhile, despite the growing number of players moving into digitally curated personalized experiences, Wayfair has an advantage in being an early mover — a way it can endear customers to the brand. In 2017, Wayfair’s direct retail revenue, which consists of sales from its five sites, was $1.4 billion, which amounts to around 30 percent of its total net revenue for that year.

Their approach to redefining search [based on images] is interesting and important,” said Danny Esner, svp of marketing at NuOrder. “Moving beyond text-based search towards image and voice is the next wave. “

As to whether Wayfair is planning to complement its digital offerings with a physical presence, Kim said it’s open to it. The company is rumored to be opening a Boston store, and this week, the city of Florence, Kentucky announced in a tweet that Wayfair would be opening a store there, where it already has a distribution center.

The post How Wayfair is personalizing how you buy your furniture online appeared first on Digiday.

Powered by WPeMatico

Tesla Doubles Loss, but Burns Less Cash Than Expected

Tesla doubled its loss in the second quarter but burned less cash than expected, as the rush of new Model 3 sales helped alleviate some pressure as the electric-car maker seeks to deliver a profit later this year.

Powered by WPeMatico

Rubicon Project Executes On Turnaround Plan In Q2

Rubicon Project beat its Q2 revenue expectations, sending the stock up 15% in after-hours trading. Rubicon Project is still in the middle of steering a huge ship out of danger: It’s burning cash faster than it can increase ad spend on its platform, the result of cutting buyer fees from the platform in November. TheContinue reading »

The post Rubicon Project Executes On Turnaround Plan In Q2 appeared first on AdExchanger.

Powered by WPeMatico

After Reportedly Losing $120 Million Last Year, Condé Nast Will Sell 3 of Its Titles

Cond? Nast looks to sell three of its titles–Bridges, Golf Digest and W–partly due to a recommendation from Boston Consulting Group, The New York Times reported. The rumored sale comes after Cond? Nast reportedly lost about $120 million last year. Cond? Nast CEO Robert A. Sauerberg Jr. intends to talk with senior staffers next week,…

Powered by WPeMatico

Facebook and the National Urban League Will Team Up to Offer Digital Training in 13 Cities

The National Urban League is doing its part to help Facebook achieve its goal of training 1 million people and small businesses in digital skills by 2020. Facebook chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg and National Urban League president Marc Morial announced at the National Urban League’s Annual Conference in Columbus, Ohio, that the two organizations…

Powered by WPeMatico

Apple Finds Success With App Store Search Ads, Hits New Markets In Asia And Europe

Search and ye shall find Apple search ads in six new markets. Starting Wednesday, developers in France, Germany, Italy, South Korea, Spain and Japan will be able to run Search Ads Advanced in the Apple Store. The product has been available in the US since 2016, and in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, Mexico, CanadaContinue reading »

The post Apple Finds Success With App Store Search Ads, Hits New Markets In Asia And Europe appeared first on AdExchanger.

Powered by WPeMatico

WhatsApp Is Getting Down to Business With Its New API

WhatsApp introduced an application-programming interface that allows businesses to manage conversations with users and gives users an easy way to start conversations with businesses. The Facebook-owned messaging app also revealed that it has been testing Facebook ads that enable users to click to WhatsApp. The process of getting businesses to engage people via WhatsApp, and…

Powered by WPeMatico

Techmeme Starts Automatically Placing Ads Next to Story Links Based on Their Context

Techmeme, the influential aggregation website for tech news, has begun placing banner ads on its website that correspond to links about specific companies or topics. Today, the company rolled out a new ad unit it’s calling “contextual ads,” which automatically show up via prepaid ad buys based on keywords. One of the first brands to…

Powered by WPeMatico

This Visual Search Tool Aims to Demystify the Value of Esports Sponsorships

The esports economy is projected to reach a little over $900 million this year, but the nascent space remains largely uncharted territory for marketers. Brands are spending 50 percent more in the space than they did last year, according to one estimate. And while three-quarters of that money comes from sponsorships, advertising and media rights,…

Powered by WPeMatico