‘Doubled our workload in a lot of places’: Confessions of a DTC media buyer on Facebook headaches caused by iOS changes

For years, direct-to-consumer brands focused digital ad dollars on Facebook to help build their brands. More recently, that strategy has proved challenging as privacy shifts due to Apple’s iOS 14 update have added difficulties with targeting as well as attribution. For the latest edition of our Confessions series, in which we trade anonymity for candor, we heard from a DTC media buyer on how the privacy changes have made his job more difficult.

This conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity.

The iOS privacy changes have had an impact on the amount of Facebook’s available data for media buyers. How has that impacted your job? 

I feel like we’re back to this needing to prove the worth of Facebook again, which was like a big part of 2015. It’s making one ad account feel like two or three. It’s doubled our workload in a lot of places. Clients just don’t think Facebook is working so we’re having to spend hours creating reports on how Facebook is having an impact on their business. 

Why’s that?  

It’s because the Facebook platform performance has dropped and we’re losing a lot of visibility of what’s working and not working. We’re using Google Analytics to tell us how well Facebook is doing. We would do this before — we’d check in here and there — but now we’re using it to make decisions about Facebook. With some accounts we’re seeing almost a two-to-one of Google Analytics conversions versus Facebook conversions.

What do you wish clients’ understood about Facebook now? 

How Facebook drives traffic across all channels. It increases organic search, branded paid search and direct traffic — a lot of Facebook traffic shows up as direct traffic — and how it works with the full ecosystem. [Clients] are seeing that smaller Facebook number but then blended ROAs is the same or better so we’re having to show them how Facebook is adding value in other areas. It should be the growth director’s job to do that. We’re kind of coaching them on how to prove the worth of it. Facebook contributes to the overall awareness and lift of everything. You need to think about it as an ecosystem rather than a single channel. 

Would you say the way that brands think about Facebook needs to shift because of the privacy shifts?

Facebook contributes to the overall awareness and lift of everything. You need to think about it as an ecosystem rather than a single channel. [Clients need to] invest in their brands. Add value to their communities. Invest in influencer marketing, organic social, and find ways to partner with other brands. 

DTC brands relied heavily on Facebook ads for years to build brands. Clearly that’s not the case anymore. How are you managing that?

For us, we’re trying to focus on more brands that are doing retail. Brands that have the omnichannel presence already get it, they know about the ecosystem and how investing in the brand can drive those retail sales so we’re trying to find more opportunities to work with those types of brands.

The post ‘Doubled our workload in a lot of places’: Confessions of a DTC media buyer on Facebook headaches caused by iOS changes appeared first on Digiday.

‘It’s just a new way of thinking’: Why consulting firm We Are Rosie is paying departing employees

Last year, murmurings started that the future of work would be found in the gig economy and project-based work. By the beginning of the year, those rumblings reached a fever pitch as the marketing and public relations industry began launching platforms like Publicist, which is geared toward freelancers

With that in mind, marketing consulting firm and freelance collective We Are Rosie this year launched an internal effort to close the financial gaps that come between projects: Commencement pay. That means when a full time employee decides to pursue a new venture, We Are Rosie will continue their salary for two weeks on top of what’s owed for the final paycheck, according to chief of staff Nikki Coleman. (Typically, employers pay out what employees have already earned and accrued vacation time, depending on the state law. Coleman declined to comment on We Are Rosie’s policy in that regard.)

It’s a move We Are Rosie hopes will create a frictionless transition not only for the departing employee, but also for the incoming talent, said chief of staff Nikki Coleman. Digiday caught up with Coleman to talk about commencement pay the gig economy and the future of work. 

This interview has been lightly edited and condensed for clarity. 

What is commencement pay and what made We Are Rosie start offering it to full time employees?

We started thinking about how to celebrate that [departure] without judgement or shame for going into the next phase. We want to thank them for their time and contribution here, so we offer everyone two weeks of pay to help them lean in and fill the gap if they’re looking for a new job or as they start their next journey.  We already had a team member that’s gone through the process.

It’s just a new way of thinking. We follow up with people like, “What are you doing now? If you ever want to come back, you can do this.” 

[It’s] going beyond the status quo. Most companies say, “Oh, we pay severance to people that we terminate.” Like, what about the people that have contributed so much to your [company’s] growth and they want to leave, but they want to leave on good terms? There’s no question or concern about the bottom line.

(In an email follow up, Coleman confirmed We Are Rosie’s commencement pay is two weeks of continued salary pay on top of the departing employee’s final paycheck.)

This seems like a service that could double as an investment in hopes to expand We Are Rosie’s network.

It’s a little bit of that too. We fully recognize that sometimes even our consultants in our community, sometimes they become our clients and they may take a job somewhere else. By talking about it, we really want to open up the minds of other employers to make them realize it’s not a bad thing [when someone leaves for another job]. Of course it might take a toll on your team if someone leaves. But if you treat your people with dignity and respect, they’re more likely to give you more of a notice and help your team transition out and to give all the information that’s needed rather than waiting until the last two weeks to give a notice.

Has that been the case so far?

That’s what we saw. Instead of leaving the unknown with the team, everyone was really prepared. It makes a much smoother transition. It also eases the stress for the team as a whole and for that person that’s made the decision. They might help interview. They might help give a really good glimpse of what it is that the job would be for the person coming in. For them to be able to share, ‘Yes, I made the decision to leave. But this is how We Are Rosie handled it and you’re in good hands here’ is really important to us.

What do you hope the rest of adland can do to curb burnout and create more flexible work environments?

I don’t think people should be shamed or judged if they’re seeking professional and personal fulfilment. I think those two things go hand in hand. With the pandemic and the way the future of work is going, people are less willing to sacrifice. They know what they want and got a glimpse of what’s really important to them. If companies don’t start to lean into that more, they will have a hard time getting the best talent in their doors.

The post ‘It’s just a new way of thinking’: Why consulting firm We Are Rosie is paying departing employees appeared first on Digiday.

One Club and Popeyes Launch Food Styling Class as Step Toward a More Inclusive Ad Industry

If you’re looking for a helpful visual tool that encapsulates the diversity issue that continues to plague the ad industry, Popeyes’ Diversity Scorecard might be of great service. In a recent assessment of its advertising, the brand reported a notable lack of BIPOC talent on the marketing and production teams, despite the fact that people…

Coinbase Hires Facebook Vet Rouch as CMO to Polish the Brand’s Image

As Coinbase finds itself in the midst of another public relations crisis, the country’s largest cryptocurrency exchange is turning to Facebook product marketing veteran Kate Rouch to stanch the cycle of bad news as its first CMO. As CNBC and other outlets reported earlier this week, Coinbase users are up in arms after being hit…

A Brief History of Bloodvertising

If I pour 6 ounces of my own blood into a gas tank, I’m just a weirdo. But if I pour it into a paint can, I’m a…provocateur. Sure, the effect is equally inconsequential, but there’s something eerily visceral about the idea of blood being infused into art or added into products that someone else…